Carol's Cookies Cookie Company
Share This:
Cookie Blog

Why Are Carol’s Cookies Special?

It doesn’t matter what new technologies have emerged or how much business has grown over the last four decades, Carol’s Cookies always has, and always will be handmade. We’ve grown from Carol’s home kitchen to now our fourth and biggest bakery yet, but we’ll never change Carol’s original homemade recipe.

We understand that there are a lot of cookies on the shelf, and we want to make sure ours stand out.  We always use the best ingredients, from our Ghirardelli chocolate to the fresh hand-cracked eggs. Our cookies aren’t machine-driven or mass-produced.  Each cookie is handmade by one of our bakers so you can taste the all natural ingredients in every bite.  We take pride in the fact that no two cookies we bake look exactly the same.  You wouldn’t expect identical cookies out of your own home kitchen.  And that’s all we are: a home kitchen with a phenomenal one-of-a-kind cookie recipe that’s expanded over the course of years to a bakery with over 30employees.

One taste of one of our nearly half-pound, handmade cookies and we’re sure you’ll see what makes Carol’s so special.  So, sit down, kick back and enjoy a Carol’s Cookie and let us know what you think and share with a friend!


Autumn Up Your Baking

We love this season (as you can see from our blog post last year: The Joys of Fall) there’s something about a crisp fall day, a glass of warm apple cider, and our snickerdoodle cookie that is what dreams are made of.

But our love doesn’t stop there.  We love fall decorations, the holidays, and the flavors (pumpkin anyone?).  And from our experience, so do a lot of you!  We wanted to share with your some of our favorite tips, tricks, and ideas for fall-themed cooking and baking.

Use fall colored candies instead of chocolate chips in your baked good recipes.  Same flavor you’d expect but with a little crunch and a very fall feel.

Add pumpkin to everything and anything!  We like to substitute pumpkin for butter and oil in things like breads, cookies, and muffins.  But we also can’t get enough of pumpkin chili, pumpkin hash and eggs, and pumpkin “noodles”!  Poodles anyone?

Use pumpkins as a fun way to serve food and drinks!  A cleaned hallowed out pumpkin takes a little work, but we think it’s worth it for such a festive serving option! They are great for dips (or to hold that pumpkin chili!) and even drinks.

What’s the color most associated with fall?  Orange of course!  You can use orange food dye in a variety of food items to give them a fall theme.  Soft boiled eggs, whipped cream, cream cheese, cake batter, popsicles, water, ice cubes, yogurt…you name it, making it orange automatically makes it feel so seasonal.

Of course there are tools you can buy that make whatever you’re making into a fall shape as well.  We love these pumpkin shaped muffin tins!

Or with a little imagination, patience and skills, you can make plenty of you favorite foods and treats look like fall things.

Have you tried any of our favorite ideas before?  How did they turn out?  Or do you have your own autumn inspired dish to share with us?  We’d love to hear.  Send us a message via facebook, twitter, or email!

Yelp Us What You Think

You might not know this, but even though we don’t have a retail bakery or storefront, you can still review us on Yelp!  Check out our page here.  We love hearing back from our fans and really, anyone who has tried our cookies.  Of course you can always tell your closest Carol’s Cookies retailer that you love our cookies to make sure they keep them in stock (and keep your eyes open for any new locations starting to carry our cookies).


But nothing’s better than coming straight to us and letting us know how you feel.


But we’re not trying to toot our own horns… to be fair, we don’t always get 4 star reviews.

Not a Yelp member? That’s okay. We love to hear from you anyway you can reach out to us. You can leave us a review on our Facebook page, in our special “Love Letters To Carol” section on our webpage, or just tweet to us letting us know what you think about our cookies @CarolsCookies.

What to do when the cookie crumbles

What to do when the cookie crumbles

Let’s set the scene:  You go to the grocery store to pick up your weekly essentials (milk, eggs, Carol’s Cookies, a watermelon, cereal, frozen pizzas) and when you get home find that somehow, your cookie slipped to the bottom of the bag and was crushed to smithereens.

Sound familiar?  What’s a cookie lover to do?!

Don’t worry, we’re here to help with recipes that use our cookie crumbs.  It’s true.  You can still enjoy the sweet, crunchy-yet-chewy, goodness of your Carol’s Cookies even though it seems as though it tried to muffle an atomic bomb.


Chocolate-Coconut Cookie Bars

  • 3 cups of finely ground Carol’s Cookie crumbs.  We suggest using our Old Fashioned Sugar Cookie
  • ¼ cup sugar
  • ¾ cup unsalted butter, melted
  • 1 cup pecan or walnut pieces
  • 1 cup ghirardelli semisweet chocolate chips
  • 1 can (14 oz) sweetened condensed milk
  • 1 ½ cup sweetened shredded coconut


  1. Preheat oven to 375 degrees.  Spritz a 15x10 inch rimmed baking sheet with water, and then line with parchment paper.
  2. In a large bowl, stir together cookie crumbs, sugar, and butter until combined.  Press evenly onto the bottom and sides of the prepared baking sheet.  Bake, turning halfway, until firm, about 10 minutes.  Transfer to a wire rack and allow for 20 minutes.
  3. Sprinkle cooled crust with pecans and chocolate.  Pour condensed milk over the top, spreading to completely cover (do not drip over the edges).  Sprinkle with coconut.
  4. Bake until coconut is toasted, 10 – 15 minutes.  Transfer to rack to cool.  Then enjoy!


No-Bake Chocolate Chip Cookie Truffles

  1. Combine cookie crumbs and cream cheese in a bowl.
  2. Roll misture into golf-ball sized balls and chill in refigerator 20-30 minutes.
  3. Melt chocolate in the microwave on low for 30 seconds at a time, stirring frequently, until all is melted and smooth.
  4. Take cookie balls from the fridge and dip in melted chocolate, covering completely.  Lift cookie balls out with a spoon and let excess chocolate drip off.  Place coated cookie balls on a baking tray lined with wax paper.
  5. Top cookie balls with additional cookie crumbs – we used our old fashioned crumbs to incorporate a different flavor.  Keep refrigerated.



Cookie Crumb Topped Cupcakes

Simply bake (or buy) your favorite cupcakes that are topped with frosting.  We made Bakerella’s Decadent Chocolate Cupcakes with Hazlenut Frosting. Once made- just dip your frosted cupcake into a bowl of your cookie crumbs.  Finish by sprinkling additional crumbs over the top of the cupcake and pressing lightly to make sure they stick.



Chocolate Cherry Cookie Crumb Bites

  • 1 cup old fashioned oats
  • 1 cup crushed Carol’s Cookies Oatmeal Chocolate Cherry cookie crumbs
  • ½ cup peanut butter (or any other nut butter)
  • 1/3 cup honey
  • ½ cup dried cherries
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract


  1. Stir all ingredients together in a medium to large size bowl until thoroughly mixed.  Cover and let chill in the refrigerator for 30 mins.
  2. Once chilled, roll into balls of about 1” in diameter.  Store in an airtight container and keep refrigerator.


Carol’s Cookie Crumb Pie Crust

You can bake along with Carol in this one!



And if you’re not up to baking….you could always scoop yourself a big bowl of ice cream and top with Carol’s Cookie crumbs and whatever other toppings you desire!

Which one are you going to try next time an unfortunate accident happens to your Carol’s Cookies?  Or do you have your own recipe to use up all the cookie crumbs?  Let us know @carolscookies with #carolscookiescrumbs on Twitter and Instagram!  We’d love to see what you come up with!



Top 10 Reasons Why Carol’s Cookies make the perfect gift

10. Have you ever met someone who honestly likes fruitcake?

9. You haven’t put the batteries back in your smoke detector since your last great baking adventure.

8. At a half pound each, you won’t need many to fill a stocking.

7. There’s no need for ties in a business casual world.

6. New Year’s resolutions haven’t started yet.

5. Who can eat an entire case of pears anyway?

4. Because Santa clears out the cookie stash every year.

3. Nothing goes better with eggnog and hot chocolate.

2. You don’t have to worry about your gift getting re-gifted.

1.  Flowers die







Getting Halloween Ready

Everyone knows this holiday is about two things.  The first is, it’s all about the candy.  Fun-size, over processed, nuggets of sugar. I’d be lying if I said I didn’t wish the tradition changed over to adorably dressed children ring doorbell, door opens, and a handful of Carol’s Cookies minis were handed out…But I digress.

The second part of Halloween, the most important part, is the costume.  Basically, if you dream it, you can be it. It can be extremely overwhelming…where do you even start?  Well, for us, it’s a bit easier.  We eat, sleep, breathe, think, and live for cookies.  So naturally, we favor costumes of the doughy, sweet treat variety.  And we couldn’t encourage you more to take suit…and suit up as your favorite treat this holiday.  And don’t forget to let us see!

Our most FAQ

We love to hear from our friends, fans, and those just learning about our cookies.  We try to be helpful and provide answers to the most Frequently Asked Questions here (http://carolscookies.com/faq).  But the one question we get asked the most is, “How do you make your cookies so big?!”  We get it.  This question comes from the same mind-boggling, inconceivable place where we wonder, “How does the Tooth Fairy get under our pillows while we sleep?” and “What type of Spanx does Santa put on to shimmy down the chimney.”  They are the universal questions that keep us up at night.

But you’re in luck!  Tonight you can sleep easy and save the worries of the world for another day.  Creating our cookies should be a snap after reading this.

To make our cookies so big, we start with using just the right amount of fats to form correct cohesion and adhesion of ingredients.  This allows our cookies to be dense, yet cooked through, chewy, yet melt in your mouth.  The molecules must be solidly brought together to form the base.  Without it, we would be left with neat little piles of eggs, flour, and Ghirardelli Chocolate.

Speaking of eggs, you want to add your eggs whole, one at a time. But that makes the mixing a little more difficult.  Egg whites are largely water and they don’t mix well with cohesion agents.  But we warn you, too much mixing and you’re in danger of over-mixing.  Over-mixing results in a holey mess that falls apart as soon as it’s lifted off the cookie sheet.  And if you’re not using the right flour, well that totally throws off the protein structure and gluten levels and the ingredients won’t be able to bind.

You’ll need acidity and carbon dioxide to create a strong protein bond with the correct flour.  If your bond isn’t strong, all the good stuff is evaporated away.  A strong bond keeps our dough stiff, and the right level of acidity firms our cooking dough faster, which results in our thick cookies (not spread thin like you so often find).  But that all goes to waste if you don’t mix enough.  The importance of the mixing time of the dough is everything.  Mix too little and you won’t get enough air pockets to be filled with CO2, mix too much and your cookie looks like meal worms invaded.

The last step to consider in making Carol’s-Cookie-sized cookies is temperature.  You want the kinetic energy of the particles to be just right.  You want to be right where the energy within the plasma collisions is high enough to overcome the Coulomb barrier and the cookie particles fuse together into one massive cookie without cracking.

And of course, the perfection of dough you just created is nothing unless you’re dropping 1/2lb softball-sized scoops of it on your cookie tray.

Now you should be set to go ahead and recreate your own version of Carol’s Cookies in your fridge.

What?  You’re confused?  Well, you didn’t really think we were going to divulge our most sacred secrets, did you?

Chicago Food Entrepreneur Series: Meet Katrina Markoff of Vosges Haut-Chocolat

Imagine being able to travel the world while indulging in delicious, hand-crafted chocolate. If it’s hard for you to imagine, fear no more! Our next Chicago Food Entrepreneur, Katrina Markoff, has made that dream possible through her world-renowned chocolate operation, Vosges Haut Chocolat.

Katrina’s business was inspired by her travels around the world. Soon after graduating from college, she journeyed to Paris to study at Le Cordon Bleu. From there, Katrina visited countries from Spain to Southeast Asia. Located in Logan Square, Vosges provided people in Chicago a way to experience the world through chocolate. Today Vosges brings joy to people all over the world through its retail locations in New York City and Las Vegas.

We had the pleasure of gaining a little more insight into the world of Vosges while speaking with Katrina. She described her chocolate as “experiential” and told us that her favorite food was chocolate!

We also wanted to know more about what Katrina thought of Carol’s Cookies. Katrina had her first Carol’s Cookie at Neiman Marcus, which is probably why she associates our cookies with Christmas shopping in Chicago.  She also thinks that what sets Carol’s Cookies apart is the fact that “Carol is an incredibly sweet person!” We asked if she was given the chance to create her own sweet, perfect cookie, what flavor it would be. Katrina confessed that Carol’s already had the perfect cookie: our sugar cookie. 

Thanks to Katrina for chatting with us! We are proud to associate with a fellow Chicago food entrepreneur who is passionate about using food to change the world.

Chicago Food Entrepreneur Series: Meet Jon Sider of Greater Than

In Chicago, we are known for our sports (Congrats Blackhawks!) and our food.  And luckily, our next Chicago Food Entrepreneur has had an effect on both. We’re happy to introduce you to Jon Sider, the co-founder of Greater Than sports drinks!

Image via Medill Northwestern


Jon and his brother, Mark Sider, felt the need to create the optimal drink for those who live an active lifestyle.  The great thing about Greater Than (no pun intended) is that it’s unlike any other sports drink you’ve heard of: no artificial color or dye, no high fructose corn syrup, and all natural ingredients. Head quartered in the Wicker Park neighborhood of Chicago, Greater Than now offers their delicious coconut water in five flavors and continues to fuel athletes in Chicago and around the country.


Image via: Lacrosse America

How would you describe your business?

Coconut Water that tastes great.  We've taken the natural goodness of Coconut Water and enhanced it for premium hydration and taste.

What inspired you to start Greater Than?

We are young, hungry and determined to be great.  It just so happens that our sport in business turned out to be hydration.  Living an active lifestyle ourselves, we believed there was a need for a more natural source of hydration.  After learning about Coconut Water, we thought that was the perfect place to start.

Image via: Kumbuya


What’s your favorite food?

My favorite indulgence is Carol's Cookies.  Plus there is nothing like a Carol's Cookies to earn a few points with the lady.


When did you have your first Carol’s Cookie?

I had my first Carol's Cookies at Sunset Valley Golf Club.  It was much greater than a first kiss.


What do you associate Carol’s Cookies with?

I associate Carol's Cookies with delicious happiness.  They're always delicious and they always make you happy.  Yum!


Name your favorite thing about Carol’s Cookies.

Carol’s is rooted in our hometown of Highland Park.  It's an entrepreneurial story that can inspire others.


If you had to create a new Carol’s Cookie, what flavor would it be?

How about some Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, topped off with Cinnamon & Sugar!  That would be a Greater Than Moment!

Thanks again to Jon for chatting with us about Greater Than (and his love of Carol’s Cookies)! All natural ingredients made us successful and we have no doubt that the same will be true for Greater Than!

Chicago Food Entrepreneur Series: Meet Dan Klein of Tiesta Tea

Chicago foodie entrepreneurs are one-of-a-kind. They exhibit drive and creativity in ways that continue to astound us! As part of our series, we spoke with Co-Founder and CEO, Dan Klein, about the methodology that makes Tiesta Tea not only unique and intriguing, but also practical.
Klein and his team have come full circle (literally) in providing loose leaf tea in innovative combinations. They brought experiences they had abroad back to the U.S. to develop a brand headquartered in River North that now provides teas globally. Their teas are marketed by the way they taste, which contain real fruit and herbs, how they should be prepared, and the benefit to the consumer enjoying the finished product.
Describe your business: We make exotic blends of loose-leaf tea categorized by function. We customize recipes that use full fruits and herbs to enhance the all-natural flavor.
How did you get into the food business? In other words, what was your inspiration? Our inspiration came from a study abroad trip my business partner Patrick and I took to Prague. We were blown away by the unique flavors and plethora of teahouses and wondered why we weren’t seeing it back home.
What’s your favorite food? Scallops, no question - Nothing like fresh seafood.
When did you have your first Carol’s Cookie? I had my first Carol’s Cookie after graduating college, when I was 22.
What do you associate Carol’s Cookies with? If I had to use one word, it would be handcrafted.
What is your favorite thing about Carol or her cookies? I love the story and the fact that they are truly handmade and all-natural. There’re very few cookies at the grocery stores these days that can claim this.
If you were to create the perfect flavor for a Carol's Cookie, what would it be? Chocolate Peanut Butter with a vanilla swirl!
A special thanks to Dan for taking the time to give us feedback on Carol’s Cookies and speak about Tiesta Tea.  Hey, Dan, which Tiesta Tea beverage would be a great combination with one of Carol’s Cookies???  Hmmm, new flavor in the making?

Chicago Food Entrepreneur Series: Meet Pam Netzky of SkinnyPop Popcorn

Our Chicago foodie blog series continues! In our last post you met Corey Kaplan of NYC Bagel Deli – a man who has wooed Chicago with his east coast-inspired bagels & cream cheese. Today’s post shares how one woman put a twist on the Midwest’s favorite snack: meet SkinnyPop Popcorn!

With the tagline, “No artificial anything,” consumers can indulge in a guilt-free snack without sacrificing flavor or enjoyment. We asked Pam Netzky, President and Co-Founder of SkinnyPop Popcorn,a few questions to get an insider's look into her booming business.

Pam was recruited by Andrew Friedman to help launch Wells Street Popcorn in 2007. Andrew and his investors were originally inspired by the success of Garrett Popcorn. Shortly after, they discovered their original business plan – a retail store model – would need to change. Pam and Andrew began experimenting with a healthier popcorn product.

Pam tells us, "I fell into the food business due to my entrepreneurial spirit” and her efforts have paid off. Pam has been featured in various media publications including the Chicago Tribune and recently made Crain's 40 Under 40 where she says, "you have to be open to change, to spot opportunities and take chances."

And, like many of our Chicago foodie friends, Pam has a special place in her heart for Carol’s Cookies.

When did you have your first Carol’s Cookie? Years ago at Neiman Marcus.

What is your favorite thing about Carol or her cookies? I love how unique the cookies are. Not much like it in the market…Aside from them being beyond delicious.

If you were to create the perfect flavor for a Carol's Cookie, what would it be? No need. It already exists: Classic Chocolate Chip. 

A special thank you to Pam for taking the time to speak to us about her business. Now it’s time for all of us to go pick up both a sweet and a savory Chicago-style treat!

Chicago Food Entrepreneur Series: Meet Corey Kaplan of NYC Bagel Deli

Chicago is a city that’s passionate about food and hard work.  Many of you know our great city for “Chicago Style” hot dogs, pizza and Italian beef. On the sweeter side of life, there are iconic companies like Garret’s Popcorn, Eli’s Cheesecake (and Carol’s Cookies!) that have left quite an impression.  On the restaurant front, we’re grateful for Lettuce Entertain You. And for the best quick lunch you’ve ever had, there’s NYC Bagel Deli. And these are just a few…


Out of respect and appreciation for our fellow foodies, we wanted to introduce you to “the brains behind the tastes.”  We hope you enjoy getting to know some of the people behind your favorite local eats!


Our first interview is with Corey Kaplan, founder of NYC Bagel Deli.  Who doesn’t love NYC Bagel Deli’s ridiculously amazing homemade cream cheese, fresh bagels and Boar’s Head deli meat & cheese?! Oh yeah, and if you’re really a true Chicagoan, you’ll grab a Carol’s Cookies to top it off!

Meet Corey Kaplan!


Where can we visit a NYC Bagel Deli?

We have three main locations: River North, Lincoln Park and South Loop. We also make NY Style thin crust pizza at the Citigroup Center food court in Ogilvie Station and sell our pizza “slices” at the River North location.

Describe your business.


My business is New York Style in Chicago… WHOAAA! So, we walk a fine line.  We have the BEST New York Style kettle boiled bagels, homemade cream cheese and Boar’s Head brand meats and cheese.

How did you get into the food business?

I got into the food business 30 years ago in New Jersey. All Jewish boys worked at a bagel shop!

What’s your favorite food?

An everything bagel with chive cream cheese, lox, tomato, capers and red onion.

When did you have your first Carol’s Cookie?

My daughter Nikki bought me a chocolate chip cookie years ago and ever since then we have been selling 20 dozen per week!!!

What do you associate Carol’s Cookies with?

Carol’s Cookies are true comfort food to me. A cookie in the microwave with chocolate chip ice cream on it, WOWWWWW!!!

What is your favorite thing about Carol or her cookies?

The fact that Carol is answering the phones and still “in the daily mix” – I LOVE IT!!!

If you were to create the perfect flavor for a Carol's Cookie, what would it be?


Thanks for taking the time to hang out with us Corey!  After writing this post, it’s safe to say we’ll see you around lunch time!